Vaccine inequity persists as African continent yet to surpass 10% vaccination rate

While the world is discussing ways to move on from the pandemic and return to normalcy, an entire continent is struggling to get even the first dose of vaccine, with little concern expressed by international bodies

November 19, 2021 by Jyotsna Singh
A health worker in Uganda prepares a vaccine dose. Photo: WHO African Region

The vaccination rate in Africa stands at 9.8%. The continent of 54 countries and 780 million people is still struggling to reach double digits in vaccinating its population. The second worst performer – Asia – has reached 60% vaccination rates. While there are discrepancies within the African continent — 65% people vaccinated in Morocco, 27% in South Africa, 5.4% in Malawi and 0.13% in Democratic Republic of Congo — the overall picture is worrisome. The rich countries and their big pharmaceutical companies have abandoned an entire continent. Following their footsteps, companies from countries like India have also not stepped up to provide vaccines to African nations.

“Some of my colleagues have started to call it racism. Letting a whole continent have such limited access to vaccines smacks of nothing less,” said Dr. Mohga Kamal-Yanni, Senior Health Policy Advisor, The Peoples Vaccine Alliance.

Failing negotiations and pooling mechanism

Developments since last year, indeed indicate towards racism and vaccine apartheid. The African Union, through the African Export-Import Bank, communicated last year that it is ready to buy vaccines and is awaiting offers from companies. Still, according to various sources, these negotiations failed despite efforts on the side of the African leadership. Even though some discussions with producers led to verbal commitments, in the end there was no final deal. All vaccine manufacturers prioritized the developed world, mainly Europe and North America.

The Africa Bureau of Presidents, chaired by South Africa’s President, Cyril Ramaphosa, agreed that member-states should target vaccinating 60% of their population. Scientists at Africa Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (Africa CDC) suggested the same. The Bureau established the Africa Vaccine Acquisition Task Force (AVAT) last year to procure the required number of vaccines collectively for all African nations. “It became pretty clear by December (2020) that the hope that we would all, as a global community, buy vaccines together through this structure called Covax, was not being adhered to, especially by rich and powerful nations,” said Mr. Strive Masiyiwa, chairperson of AVAT in a press conference on 1 July, 2021.

“We nevertheless engaged the donor community. They made it clear from the beginning that they would never go beyond 20% for our population in donor support which meant that Africa would have to acquire the additional vaccines itself if it wanted to get to 60%,” added Masiyiwa. The task force was given the responsibility to raise the money to help the African nations acquire the vaccines. AVAT initiated talks with the World Bank as early as November 2020 and Masiyiwa pointed out that those discussions were successful. “What was less successful was just the availability of the vaccines. It really didn’t matter how much money a country had. They couldn’t buy the vaccines,” said Masiyiwa. He informed that the leadership of many African countries tried to connect with manufacturers and Chief Executives of many companies but they could not procure the vaccines.

“Even the Serum Institute of India was not forthcoming in supplying vaccines to the African nations,” says Fatima Hassan, founder of Health Justice Initiative. She said that profiteering of the pharmaceutical industry, backed by governments of rich countries, has led to such a disastrous situation in Africa.

A prominent example of how the world failed Africa is the backfiring of Covax in providing promised doses to developing countries. Covax is the vaccine pillar of ACT-Accelerator, an initiative of various stakeholders in the health sector, such as the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation and Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance. Pharmaceutical companies were supposed to voluntarily pool their technology and manufactured vaccines in Covax, while rich nations were to pay for a given number of doses to be shipped to lower and middle-income countries. According to the original plan, Covax was supposed to procure enough doses of COVID-19 vaccines for countries to vaccinate up to 20% of their population in the long term – a goal that has been deemed as extremely under-ambitious from the very beginning of the initiative. However, companies never shared their technology, and not enough doses were pooled even to reach this threshold.

Covax has been able to sign up for 4,274 million doses so far through different sources. Some of these will be shipped to Africa. Compared to this, the US alone has agreements for 3,210 million doses. The African Union, on the other hand, has been able to sign agreements for only 510 million doses. There is no individual African country in the top 15 countries to have signed agreements for the requisite number of doses. The US has recently announced that it will donate 1000 million doses to Covax and some of it will be channeled to Africa. Details of this announcement are still awaited.

Local production as a way out

An effective way of addressing this inequality is local production of vaccines. Yet, the multinational pharmaceutical companies have thrashed all attempts to boost local production capacities. In an attempt to ramp up production of vaccines for the whole world, the World Health Organization (WHO) has established the South Africa mRNA Technology Transfer Hub; but Pfizer, which was among the first few companies to have developed an mRNA COVID-19 vaccine, did not share its technology. On the contrary, it bypassed this mechanism and signed a bilateral deal for vaccine production with the South African government. The agreement was shrouded in secrecy, but leaked information suggests that instead of transferring technology, Pfizer is only allowing for fill and finish. The active pharmaceutical ingredient will continue to be Pfizer’s monopoly.

“It is a very narrow and restrictive deal. African manufacturers can do a lot more,” said Zain Rizvi of Public Citizen, a US-based think tank that has been following the business of big pharma for a long time, especially during the pandemic.

Another American company, Johnson & Johnson also entered into an agreement with South Africa for vaccine production. However, it turned out that the company planned to export the doses produced in South Africa to Europe, instead of circulating them on the continent where they were manufactured. As a timely investigative story appeared in the New York Times, J&J took a step back in this plan and started supplying in Africa too. Still, the agreement they signed with the government of South Africa remains one to fill and finish, not of technology transfer, which undermines the possibility of ramping up production.

Pfizer and J&J have pledged notoriously low numbers of doses to meet the needs of developing countries. Pfizer has supplied only 40 million doses to Covax, less than 1% of the total doses procured by Covax so far. Janssen, a subsidiary of J&J, has given 500 million doses. J&J has also agreed to supply 400 million doses to the African Union to distribute across Africa. In comparison, Pfizer is supplying 2,404 billion doses to the European Commission and 314 million doses to Japan.

It is difficult to find detailed information on agreements between countries and companies. “Pfizer is known to sign a non-disclosure agreement even before starting negotiations to bar even the information about negotiations happening going out,” said Rizvi. However, going by the number of vaccinated people in Africa, it doesn’t seem like negotiations have led to more doses being made available.

Meanwhile, the companies have made enormous profit on vaccine production in the last months. Pfizer has made USD 31 billions in 2021 from its vaccine alone. J&J earned USD 502 million in sales from its COVID-19 vaccine in the third quarter, and it has already earned USD 264 million in the first six months of 2021.

Read more articles from the latest edition of the People’s Health Dispatch and subscribe to the newsletter here.